Erik Forsyth saw this bird on the Hauraki Gulf on the 25th (with Brett on Assassin). Erik wonders if it could be a juv pink-footed shearwater. Thoughts?
Shearwater ID help
- Neil Fitzgerald
- Site Admin
- Posts: 3637
- Joined: Mon May 18, 2009 10:20 am
- Location: Hamilton, New Zealand
- Contact:
- Neil Fitzgerald
- Site Admin
- Posts: 3637
- Joined: Mon May 18, 2009 10:20 am
- Location: Hamilton, New Zealand
- Contact:
- erikforsyth
- Posts: 201
- Joined: Sat Aug 03, 2013 9:16 pm
Re: Shearwater ID help
Hi all
i have a few other pics which show this bird feeding on chum amongst a group of flesh-footed shearwaters. In these pictures you can see straight away how pale this bird appears compared to the dark brown flesh-footed' s. I will try get these pics downloaded asap.
Best wishes
Erik forsyth
Rockjumper Birding Tours
www.rockjumperbirding.com
0212657727
i have a few other pics which show this bird feeding on chum amongst a group of flesh-footed shearwaters. In these pictures you can see straight away how pale this bird appears compared to the dark brown flesh-footed' s. I will try get these pics downloaded asap.
Best wishes
Erik forsyth
Rockjumper Birding Tours
www.rockjumperbirding.com
0212657727
-
- Posts: 1008
- Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2010 10:22 pm
Re: Shearwater ID help
Buller's shearwater. Fresh feathers were grey, but faded to brown. A dead Buller's shearwater found dead on May (autumn) had worn brown & pale brown plumage, but had many new bluish grey scapular & mantle feathers and worn unmoulted brown flight feathers.
Buller's shearwaters winters on sea, west of North America and around Hawaii.
Buller's shearwaters start to moult their flight feathers on March to May, and finish on July to September, with adults start to moult on May, and finish on September. juveniles start to moult their flight feathers on March and finish on July.
By October, adults are in fresh plumages and no moult, with silvery grey rump, mantle, scapulars, secondaries and primaries.
http://hbs.bishopmuseum.org/birds/rlp-m ... S-HRBP.htm
One adult Buller's shearwater had primaries 10th and secondaries 3rd and 4th and 13th, 14th are not fully grown on 23rd September 2012.
http://shearwaterjourneys.blogspot.co.n ... nchez.html
Adult Sooty shearwater had primaries 10th not filly grown on 23/9/2012.
Buller's shearwaters winters on sea, west of North America and around Hawaii.
Buller's shearwaters start to moult their flight feathers on March to May, and finish on July to September, with adults start to moult on May, and finish on September. juveniles start to moult their flight feathers on March and finish on July.
By October, adults are in fresh plumages and no moult, with silvery grey rump, mantle, scapulars, secondaries and primaries.
http://hbs.bishopmuseum.org/birds/rlp-m ... S-HRBP.htm
One adult Buller's shearwater had primaries 10th and secondaries 3rd and 4th and 13th, 14th are not fully grown on 23rd September 2012.
http://shearwaterjourneys.blogspot.co.n ... nchez.html
Adult Sooty shearwater had primaries 10th not filly grown on 23/9/2012.
-
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Sun Jul 10, 2011 10:39 am
Re: Shearwater ID help
So whats everyone's hypothesis? This is a Buller shearwater that is partially melanistic and partially leucistic???
An interesting idea but I think genetically impossible...
Bullers have a deathly white underwing but this one has a heavily mottled underwing.
Bullers have a slate grey bill this has a yellow/off white and black bill
Bullers have bi-coloured legs this ones are mostly pink
Bullers are grey and black above this one is brown
I agree with Erik this is a good candidate for a PFS but I don't think it is as PFS are a really bulky bird with a boffy head and a really pink base to the bill and even scruffy ones have a clear demarcation between the breast and the belly.
I toyed with a pale phase Wedgie but there are too many differences - I think that this is just a leucistic (gradual whitening) fleshy-foot.
P
An interesting idea but I think genetically impossible...
Bullers have a deathly white underwing but this one has a heavily mottled underwing.
Bullers have a slate grey bill this has a yellow/off white and black bill
Bullers have bi-coloured legs this ones are mostly pink
Bullers are grey and black above this one is brown
I agree with Erik this is a good candidate for a PFS but I don't think it is as PFS are a really bulky bird with a boffy head and a really pink base to the bill and even scruffy ones have a clear demarcation between the breast and the belly.
I toyed with a pale phase Wedgie but there are too many differences - I think that this is just a leucistic (gradual whitening) fleshy-foot.
P
-
- Posts: 1008
- Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2010 10:22 pm
Re: Shearwater ID help
I think this is a rare melanistic Buller's shearwater.
- RussCannings
- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2014 5:23 am
Re: Shearwater ID help
It's a weird bird but I can't make it into anything other than a Bullers (legs/feet look fine, upperside pattern, crown/nape pattern, Bill shape). Just has that pale Bill and added brown for some reason. Intermediate WT and FF x BU hybrid crossed my mind but 'weird Bullers' just fits better to my eye.
Russ C
Cambridge, NZ
Russ C
Cambridge, NZ
- sav
- Posts: 929
- Joined: Fri Jul 03, 2009 9:49 am
- Location: Havelock North
- Contact:
Re: Shearwater ID help
I agree with Russ. That is to say, "I really don't know, but..."
If you just look at the structure and jizz of the bird it is a Buller's without doubt. The upperside pattern is Bullers.
What doesn't fit is the dirty brown underside, including the under-wing, and the pale bill (which I can't see any "yellow" in by the way, SCO??).
I think it is miles away from being a Pink-footed or Wedgetail, and even squinting really hard I can't make it look like a Fleshy.......
And you dont have to put a name to every bird you see anyway!
Cheers
If you just look at the structure and jizz of the bird it is a Buller's without doubt. The upperside pattern is Bullers.
What doesn't fit is the dirty brown underside, including the under-wing, and the pale bill (which I can't see any "yellow" in by the way, SCO??).
I think it is miles away from being a Pink-footed or Wedgetail, and even squinting really hard I can't make it look like a Fleshy.......
And you dont have to put a name to every bird you see anyway!
Cheers
- Neil Fitzgerald
- Site Admin
- Posts: 3637
- Joined: Mon May 18, 2009 10:20 am
- Location: Hamilton, New Zealand
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 1310
- Joined: Tue Oct 18, 2011 10:05 am
Re: Shearwater ID help
Yeah that last photo definitely screams aberrant Bullers to me. Curious bird though!